As part of the 18th-century competition for Native American lands, trade, and military alliances, European powers presented Indian leaders with so-called "Indian Peace medals" - the larger the medal, the more important the leader was thought to be.
Britain's Native American allies received medals depicting King George III and the royal coat of arms. Those who later allied with the United States traded in their British medals for American ones, as visible signs of their new allegiance.
George Washington faced the challenge of adapting monarchical practices to republican ideals. Because no American mint possessed the technology to produce large dies, these medals were hand-engraved by individual silversmiths on thin plates of rolled silver, making each medal unique.
Near the end of his presidency, George Washington directed Secretary of War James McHenry to order new peace medals. Three different designs explicitly promoted the adoption of settled agriculture, depicting a man sowing wheat, another herding cattle, and two women spinning and weaving beside a hearth.
The Lewis and Clark Expedition of 1804-1805 distributed nearly five dozen of these medals to leaders of Plains and Rocky Mountain nations, whose nomadic cultures and reliance on animal hides could hardly have been more distant from the medallic scenes of farming and textile production.
During Thomas Jefferson’s presidency, American peace medals returned to the traditional model: a profile portrait of the head of state, symbolically affirming a personal connection of the Native American leader to the president.
In March 1776, Congress marked the British retreat from Boston by commissioning a gold medal honoring the victorious commander in chief, George Washington. Later, as the Revolution raged on, Congress ordered additional gold and silver medals to honor ten commanders of six notable victories. The designs included portrait busts, allegorical figures, and battle scenes.
Secretary of State Thomas Jefferson hoped to distribute sets of the medals as diplomatic gifts to “each of the Crowned heads in Europe” (excepting the British king!). This grand plan was never achieved, likely due to its high cost and the political turmoil of the French Revolution. President Washington received the only known original set of silver Comitia Americana medals.
America’s first military decoration was bestowed only once—for the capture of British spy Major John André in September 1780. Congress bestowed the Fidelity Medal to three New York militiamen, John Paulding, Isaac Van Wart, and David Williams, for “nobly disdaining to sacrifice their country for the sake of gold, … whereby the dangerous and traitorous conspiracy of Benedict Arnold was brought to light, … and the United States rescued from impending danger.”
News of the decisive victory at Yorktown in October 1781 prompted Benjamin Franklin, the American minister to France, to commission a medal commemorating the Declaration of Independence and the victorious French-American alliance. The result is considered a masterpiece of medallic art.
Three early medals pay tribute to Benjamin Franklin as scientist and diplomat, highlighting his discovery of electricity and invention of the lightning rod. Surviving sketches from engraver Augustin Dupré show how the design and symbolism of the 1784 medal evolved.
Gift-giving was an established part of 18th-century diplomacy. George Washington approved Thomas Jefferson’s suggestion for a gold medal to be “the American present” for retiring ministers from European nations. These trial impressions, called “splashers,” were made in lead to test the die.